Public Forums

View latest posts View Archive

Help - anyone else's child in meltdown over SATS?

April 28, 2019 09:00

Hi all,

To cut a long story short, my AD (age 7, in year 2) has FASD and sensory processing difficulties. She's way behind in school and struggling to cope. The school applied for an EHCP but according to our local authority panel, my AD is managing okay (despite every other professional disagreeing, including her class teacher who isn't quite sure how she's going to get through the rest of the school year as things stand!)

I'm awaiting a date for mediation, but in the meantime AD is so stressed at school with all the build up and practise papers for the SATS that's she's going into shutdown mode throughout the day. Her teacher says she was really vacant and 'far away' on Thursday and none of the teachers could reach her, which I find quite alarming. She sobbed on Thursday evening and said 'Why am I so stupid?' so I kept her off on Friday and emailed the school to say that unless they can confirm that AD won't have to sit the SATS (her teacher agrees that she won't even manage the first page of questions), I won't be sending her back until June when the SATS are over.

Her teacher called me on Friday and said that the head was not happy and won't allow her to be off for May - so what I'm wondering is, where do I stand? Am I, as her parent, able to boycott the SATS? Or remove my consent? Her teacher agrees that she won't learn anything from the tests and they will be crushing to her self esteem, but she says that every child has to sit them according to government regulations - anyone know if this is the case?

Any advice/experience much appreciated x

Edited 17/02/2021
Sunny11 April 28, 2019 09:37

Hi Alsa, my daughter really struggles with anxiety, she has been struggling to attend school and her anxiety at it's highest affected all parts of her life. Our GP signed her off school for a month due to her mental health. Maybe this could be a route for you? SATS are clearly having an affect on your daughter's wellbeing.

I'm not sure if you can ask for your child not to do SATS my daughter was not in school during that period in year 2. Hopefully someone else will come along with their experience of this.

Edited 17/02/2021
Safia April 28, 2019 11:44

They can be disapplied from SATS - at least they could when my daughter did them - and to be frank it’s in the school’s interest to do so - as she’s only 7 the school seems to be putting them under a lot of unnecessary pressure - usually they manage to do these without children being too aware what they are doing - unlike the year 6 ones which are generally a huge pressure. The GP is another option or If you could find out the dates more precisely just keep her off those days. I thought it was a week for each level not the whole month so maybe ring the LEA if the head or teacher isn’t telling you.

Edited 17/02/2021
Serrakunda27 April 28, 2019 13:29

Hi, Imwork in DfE. The statutory duty is in the school to administer the tests. They are required to register all children, even if the child does not sit the tests. The headteacher can apply discretion to withdraw a child in special circumstances. I'm in work tomorrow and will locate the relevant guidance and post a link.

Edited 17/02/2021
Safia April 28, 2019 14:06

Maybe they’ve changed it since my AD was disapplied - it was a long time ago - and I guess the dfe would want to make sure schools didn’t abuse this. Even if she’s off sick they may ask her to take them when she’s back - but this may be less stressful for her - the other thing you could ask is if she could take these in the separate arrangements they make for those with SEN - a small groups in the library or somewhere - maybe you could ask for that and get the GP to write / do a sick note supporting this - this is usually less stressful and there will be an adult there able to support (without telling the answers) - sometimes a child may need someone to read the questions for them - or maybe help them stay calm

Edited 17/02/2021
April 28, 2019 14:25

Thanks so much for your replies. And that would be great, Serrakunda, if you can post a link. Yes it would be helpful to have someone sitting with her but she can barely even write so she would struggle to record the answers even if she understood them, which is highly unlikely. Good idea about asking for her to sit somewhere quiet - if she must sit them I will ask for that. Thanks again x

Edited 17/02/2021
Serrakunda27 April 28, 2019 17:26

Alsa, this is the guidance

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/754071/Key_stage_2_assessment_and_reporting_arrangements.pdf

look at the top of page 24, heads have discretion. If the head won't budge I'd go to your GP and get her signed off sick. Its just not worth it. My son was in special school at 7 and didnt do them. Not made any difference to him

Edited 17/02/2021
Newt April 28, 2019 23:52

Hi Alsa,

Can I check which Key Stage your daughter is in? If it's KS1 (7 years old) then the SATs are not 'as compulsory' as at KS2. Teachers can use the reading test, for instance, to help them to double check their own ongoing teacher assessment, but there's no legal requirement to do so. The same page (p24) as Serrakunda27 mentioned above, but in the KS1 booklet, tells you more about the reasons for disapplying. I would hazard a guess that your daughter would come under the first two bullet points on p24. The KS1 booklet is here: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/754076/Key_stage_1_assessment_and_reporting_arrangements.pdf

Also see p25 about Access Arrangements, especially bullet points 2 & 3. One Access Arrangement I've heard of, that reduces stress and caters to needs, is that in a smaller quieter room, someone could help her by reading the test out loud to her, reading the questions and jotting down her answers. They would gain an overview of her listening comprehension in this way. For her own reading, if she is not yet reading at an age-appropriate level, fluently, then she is highly likely to struggle and "they are working below the overall standard of the KS1 tests (and are considered to be unable to answer the easiest questions)" (ARA p24).

The 'Teacher Assessment Frameworks' for reading, writing and maths are the only compulsory things for them to assess against at KS1 - these are lists of skills and knowledge that the teachers do not need to run tests for. They can confirm ongoing judgements against ongoing activities and work they've set previously. This is where it is different from KS2. See p2 bullet point 4, and top paragraph of p3 here: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/740343/2018-19_teacher_assessment_frameworks_at_the_end_of_key_stage_1_WEBHO.pdf

The school's Senco/Inco should be able to advise more (maybe ask this helpful classteacher to arrange a chat between the three of you?). The school receives Pupil Premium Plus funding for your child, so there should be access to additional funds for exactly this sort of support, and I would hope some to address the learning gaps and anxiety. Your Local Authority's Virtual School Head has a role to advocate for these children too:

"Virtual school heads promote the educational achievement of the children who are looked after by the local authority they work for. They also manage pupil premium plus funding, which is an extra payment that schools receive for each looked-after child, and previously looked-after child, on their roll."

I think it's worth going to the Senco/Inco and discussing access arrangements or forms of teacher assessment that allow your daughter to truly shine. After all, even if she is disapplied, the school still has to report her data in amongst everyone else's and there is a very big national focus on children who receive Pupil Premium (incl her), so it's in everybody's best interests for all sorts of reasons. My concerns next would be: and so what next for helping her to cope with her difficulties, deal with anxiety and to catch up with her peers as much as possible??

I hope that helps a bit.

Edited 17/02/2021
April 29, 2019 07:19

Thanks so much all, and thank you for all your research, Serrakunda and Newt, that is so helpful - my reply took so long because I had to register twice more to get access to these new forums! I am actually the original poster, Alsa, but couldn't login under that name as it wasn't recognised!

At least I can go into a meeting at the school this week armed with accurate info, very grateful to you all x

Edited 17/02/2021
Newt May 10, 2019 00:00

Hi Remy. Did your meeting go okay?

x

Edited 17/02/2021

Read-Only

This topic is read-only. You must log in to reply.